Build Your Own 12-Count Cookie Case view 1

Case File · Cookie Cases

Build Your Own 12-Count Cookie Case

The full jury is here. Build your case with 12 cookies and select the flavor for each one using the flavor picker. Mix your favorites or repeat a flavor you love—the verdict is yours.

Select your 12 cookies

0 / 12

Your box so far

No cookies filed yet. Pick 12 from the docket.

Quantity

Cookies — choose 12

0 / 12 selected

The Classic Case (Chocolate Chip)PB Alibi (Peanut Butter)Oatmeal Testimony (Oatmeal)Vanilla Objection (Vanilla Sugar)Berry Strong Evidence (Strawberry Crunch)Pecan in Custody (Butter Pecan)The Fun Case (Vanilla Sprinkle)Pudding Evidence (Banana Pudding)Butter on the Record (Cookie Butter)Nothing to Hide (Kitchen Sink)The Whole Truth (Oatmeal Craisin Walnut)M&M Case File (Peanut Chocolate Candy)Brownie on The Scene (Brownie Cookie)The Cosmic Case (Cosmic Brownie Cookie)Triple Threat (Triple Chocolate Chip)Dual Evidence (Milk Chocolate & White Chocolate Chip)Cookies & Cream Confession (Cookies & Cream Cookie)Campfire Conviction (S'mores)Banana Nut Case (Banana Walnut)Crunch on Appeal (Banana Crunch)The Pink Slip (Strawberry Banana)White Collar Crime (Vanilla Stripe)The Layla Special (Strawberry Fancy Sprinkle)Berry Innocent (Strawberry Butter Cookie)Roll Call (Cinnamon Roll Cookie)Guilty of Butter (Brown Butter Sugar Cookie)

Selections are for each case. To order different assortments, add each case separately.

Number of cases

Select 12 more cookies

Baked fresh to order. Place orders 72 hours in advance when possible.

Case File

The full jury is here. Build your case with 12 cookies and select the flavor for each one using the flavor picker. Mix your favorites or repeat a flavor you love—the verdict is yours.

Includes 12 cookies. Choose a flavor for each cookie and mix and match from the available menu.

Pickup & Delivery

Free local pickup in Hillsborough, New Jersey. The exact address is included in your confirmation email.

For added convenience, we offer limited drop-off service to select locations throughout New Jersey by request. Availability is limited, and a delivery fee may apply based on the destination.

All sales are final. Every dessert is made fresh to order.

Storage & Allergens

Keep cookies and brownies in an airtight container at room temperature. Refrigerate cake jars and frosted desserts.

Prepared in a home kitchen that also handles wheat, milk, eggs, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts. Cross-contact is possible.

Build Your Own 12-Count Cookie Case

Select your 12 cookies

Your box so far

also like

Build Your Own 4-Count Cookie Case

Build Your Own 6-Count Cookie Case

Build Your Own 2-Count Brownie Case

Build Your Own 4-Count Brownie Case